Archive for books

Looking at various Marvelous Land of Oz adaptations

Posted in books, comic books, Wizard of Oz with tags , , , , on March 8, 2012 by Paxton

Following the Yellow Brick Road

After reading the original Oz book, I looked at a few of the pop culture adaptations of the book.  So, now that I’ve read Oz book 2, let’s see what adaptations were released for this book.

Return to Oz
Return to Oz – A 1985 film that was an “unofficial” sequel to MGM’s The Wizard of Oz. It utilized plot points from books 2 (Marvelous Land of Oz) and 3 (Ozma of Oz) but took mostly from book 2.

Marvel Tresury of Oz 2
Marvel Treasury of Oz #2 – The Marvelous Land of Oz – I mentioned last time that in 1975 Marvel and DC collaborated for the first time on an adaptation of MGM’s Wonderful Wizard of Oz.  Marvel did one followup to that book, it was The Marvelous Land of Oz seen here.  There was no movie to adapt so they adapted the book, however, they used images and character likenesses from the MGM movie.  This is fairly rare, I’d like to track one down one day to give it a read.  I bet it’s pretty good.

Tin Man
Tin Man – A 2007 re-imagining of Wizard of Oz by the Sci-Fi Network. This mini-series took many of its plot elements from the second book in the series.  It starred Zooey Deschanel as DG (Dorothy Gale), Neal McDonough as Wyatt Cain (Tin Man) and Alan Cumming as Glitch (Scarecrow).

Review of Oz Book 2: The Marvelous Land of Oz by L Frank Baum (1904)

Posted in books, movies, pop culture, Wizard of Oz with tags , , , , , , on March 5, 2012 by Paxton

Following the Yellow Brick Road

And so I continue my journey down the yellow brick road. A few weeks ago I finished the original Wizard of Oz book by L Frank Baum and posted my review here. Now it’s time to continue the series with Book 2: The Marvelous Land of Oz.

Marvelous Land of Oz

I mentioned previously that I’ve read the original Oz book several times.  I have never read any of the other books in the series.  EVER.  So this was the first time I’d delved in to the original Baum Oz sequels in my life.  Needless to say, I was a little nervous but also excited.

First, a little background on this book. It was published in 1904, four years after the original Oz book. Baum had not intended to write a sequel. There was a stage play adaptation of the first book in 1902 that became very popular. Baum actually dedicates the book to comedians David Montgomery and Fred Stone who portrayed the Tin Man and Scarecrow in that stage production. It should also be noted that this book’s story and structure was written with an eye towards adapting it as a stage play. You will notice these elements as you read the story.  Baum also stated in the foreward that he decided to write the sequel due to the large volumes of mail he received from young fans asking for more adventures in Oz. Baum included the Tin Man and Scarecrow in the book because they were the most popular characters with fans.

Now, to the book itself.  It’s actually not bad. Baum’s boundless imagination really shines through. The structure of this book is very similar to the first Oz book, but Baum populates the story with so many fun and interesting characters you can’t help but be charmed by it.  Dorothy doesn’t appear, though she’s mentioned a few times.  Neither does the Cowardly Lion appear.  The story seems to take place a few years after Dorothy’s departure.  It centers on an eclectic group led by new character Tip who is being raised by the witch Mombi.  He flees the witch after she threatens to turn him into a garden statue and takes a walking talking pumpkin-headed man named Jack with him.  Along the way they acquire a Saw Horse, the original Scarecrow, King of Emerald City and the original Tin Man, Emporer of the Winkies.  They also acquire HM Wogglebug, TE and a magically re-animated creature called the Gump.

Woggle-bug and group
The group meets HM Wogglebug, TE.

This group travels across Oz after an army of girls takes over the Emerald City.  The group try to get to Glinda the Good Witch to get her help in expelling the army.  There’s a lot of talk about the Wizard and Baum certainly does his fair share of ret-conning the character of the Wizard.  Amongst the denizons of Oz the Wizard is no longer considered a non-magical “humbug” but a bumbling good natured fellow who happened to be a bad wizard (although an actual “wizard” nonetheless).  It is also shown that the Wizard wasn’t as reclusive as he was during the first book.  No one had really ever seen him before when Dorothy arrived at the Emerald City, but in this book Mombi mentions at one point that she was visited by the actual Wizard and that he taught her several magical tricks as payment for a big favor she performed (revealed later in the book).  There is even a discussion of who ruled Oz before the wizard showed up, which I think is interesting Oz history.  This means the Wizard showed up, battled the previous ruler of Oz, won and then usurped the throne.  That’s most definitely a change in character for the previously bumbling character.  And I like it.  But this is just the beginning as we see an army of girls sack the Emerald City, the Scarecrow lose all of his stuffing (again!) and have it replaced with actual money and a magical chase through Oz featuring Glinda the Good and Mombi.  We even see the Deadly Desert that has been mentioned in both books that surrounds the land of Oz.  This “deadly” desert in later books will turn anyone who touches it into sand.  Just not this time.  Anyway, the group of heroes save the Emerald City and there is much rejoicing.

Oh, I forgot, this book mentions several times the Tin Woodsman’s proper name, Nick Cutter. I don’t remember that being mentioned in the first book, but it’s mentioned in this book several times. I thought that was weird. When it came up at first I was like, “Who the f**k is Nick Cutter?!”. It’s the Tin Woodsman. Interesting trivia for you.

So, in the first book, the beheadings count was up to 42, all but one being doled out by Mr Cutter.  However, there are no beheadings in this book which causes the series average to plummet to 21.   I’ll be keeping track of the beheadings as I read.  We’ll see if anyone gets their heads chopped off in Book 3 (fingers crossed).

So if you are interested in more Oz goodness, definitely give this book a chance.  It’s a fun read.

Here is my checklist of the Oz books and I’ve checked off the ones I’ve read so far. Up next is Ozma of Oz.
Oz books checklist

Looking at various Wonderful Wizard of Oz adaptations

Posted in books, movies, pop culture, Wizard of Oz with tags , , , , , on February 24, 2012 by Paxton

Following the Yellow Brick Road

Earlier this week I posted my review of Baum’s first and most famous Oz novel, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz.  Now let’s take a look at some of the adaptations/re-interpretations of that original Oz book.

There were several Broadway and stage plays of the Wizard of Oz especially in the nearly 40 years between the release of the novel and the production of the MGM movie.  Baum originally had no intention of writing an Oz sequel but he did produce a stage play of the novel.  The popularity of one of these stage plays directly led to Baum writing the first Oz sequel.

Wizard of Oz
The Wizard of Oz (1939) – The original MGM musical. At this point, this movie is probably more well known than the books.  I watched it on Blu-Ray right after I finished the book.  I love this movie so much.  It’s just amazing.  Every time I watch it I love it more.  I think I’ve mentioned that I own the soundtrack and you should know I’ve been listening to it all week.

Journey Back to Oz
Journey Back to Oz (1974) – Animated movie that is the “official” sequel to the 1939 MGM movie. Not really based on any of the other Oz books. The producers really went all out. Dorothy is voiced by Judy Garland’s daughter, Liza Minelli. Margaret Hamilton who played the Wicked Witch in the 1939 movie voiced Aunt Em in this sequel. The audio track for this movie was recorded in 1964. It took 10 years for the producers to raise enough money to complete the animation which was done in 1974.  This is the first time I remember seeing the character Jack Pumpkinhead who actually shows up in Baum’s later books.

Marvelous Wizard of Oz comic
MGM’s Marvelous Wizard of Oz (1975) – The first comic collaboration between Marvel and DC. Written by Roy Thomas and drawn by John Buscema and Tony DeZuniga. It’s a straight adaptation of the MGM movie.  Nothing more, nothing less.  Great art, though.  Marvel continued this series with one more issue which you’ll see in my next installment.

Continue reading

Review of Oz Book 1: The Wonderful Wizard of Oz by L Frank Baum (1900)

Posted in books, movies, pop culture, Wizard of Oz with tags , , , , , , on February 22, 2012 by Paxton

Following the Yellow Brick Road

Earlier this year I vowed that I was going to read all of the original 14 Oz books this year. And to hold myself accountable, I’m going to blog reviews of the books as I read them.

And so the journey begins.

Wonderful Wizard of Oz cover 1

I began my reading with my Books of Wonder copy of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. I’ve read this two or three times now, but it’s such a quick and easy read I had no problem jumping right in.

It’s hard not to compare this book to the 1939 movie with Judy Garland and company. That movie is so iconic it’s tough not to picture it when you are reading.  However, I did my best.  Denslow’s illustrations really help, though.  Plus, the basics of the plot in this book are woven all through the movie.  But the differences between this book and the movie make the book that much more endearing.

Wizard of Oz 1st edition
Wizard of Oz 1st edition

Like I said, the basics are the same.  Young Dorothy and her dog Toto are whisked away to the land of Oz by a cyclone leaving behind Aunt Em and Uncle Henry.  There she travels to the City of Emeralds to see Oz, the great and powerful, in hopes that he can return her to Kansas.  Along the way she meets the Scarecrow, Tin Woodsman and the Cowardly Lion.  While these basics are the same, the journey these characters make is different and much more dangerous than the MGM movie.

Some of the differences in the book include Dorothy meeting the Good Witch of the North in Munchkinland instead of Glinda, the Good Witch of the South (who she meets in the movie).  Glinda doesn’t show up until the very end of the book.  Also, and I think many people know this now, the magical shoes are silver in the book instead of ruby.  We also don’t meet the Wicked Witch of the West face to face (they talk a lot about her) until the last third of the book.  And those are just some of the differences to the movie.

Continue reading

Year End Book Report: The Best Books I Read in 2011

Posted in books, comic books with tags , , , , , on February 7, 2012 by Paxton

Badass Book Report

Here we are, I finally begin my year end round up articles. In February. Sorry about that. I wanted to do it earlier but I wanted to give myself a little bit more time to finish off some movies and books that are eligible for this list. But, apologies aside, my lists are here.

As you know, back in 2009 I started keeping a book log with everything I read. It makes looking at this list easier. I keep it in a Google Spreadsheet so I can access it from any computer.

Here it is.

My Book Log

You can click the image to view it or just click here.  So I perused this list and made my selections.  Below are the best books I read last year (not including re-reads).

Unlike last year, I’ve split this list into books and comics/trade paperbacks.  I read enough of both of them to create their own lists and it was hard to weed out stuff just because it was a comic in order to make room for a book.  So, last year I only read three books that were actually released during the 2011 calendar year.  Did they make the list?  Read on to find out.

So without further ado, here are my favorite books I read in 2011.

Lost Hero Son of Neptune
Heroes of Olympus series – Rick Riordan – This is the sequel series to Riordan’s Percy Jackson series which made my inaugural best of list in 2009. It is currently up to book 2.  Son of Neptune is one of the three books that was released in 2011 that I read. I loved the first book in this series, The Lost Hero and Son of Neptune is almost as good. Riordan has created a fascinating world and I long to return to it when book 3 comes out.  And despite what Riodan had said earlier, Percy Jackson is all over this series.  Especially Son of Neptune.

The Magicians
The Magicians – Lev Grossman – Wow, this book is really good. It’s billed as sort of a Harry Potter in high school, and I see the parallels, but this story is tonally a 180 from Harry Potter. From the friendships to even how magic is actually executed, it’s just completely different. And great. This book is great. I look forward to checking out the sequel, The Magician King.  I’ll probably check out a few of Grossman’s other books, too.

Darth Bane 1 Darth Bane 2 Darth Bane 3
Star Wars: Darth Bane trilogy – Drew Karpyshyn – This series was recommended to me years ago by my friend Dr Mike, but I was reluctant to read it because it was about a bunch of Star Wars characters I didn’t know in a time period I knew nothing about.  Boy was I wrong.  It’s amazing.  This series needs to be the template for all the Star Wars books that want to focus on a specific character.  Interesting origins, cool bits of Sith history.  It’s just great.  If you read Star Wars (or science fiction) at all, read this series.

Continue reading